To Fuzzy Door Productions and Peacock,

Tens of thousands of us, with adult money we frankly shouldn’t spend on audiobooks, but we do, have followed Dungeon Crawler Carl through Jeff Hays’ voice. Jeff didn’t just narrate; he embodied it. His performance is the heartbeat of these characters, and without him, well, you risk alienating that entire base.

If done right, we’ll support this adaptation with enthusiasm and, yes, our wallets. Don’t underestimate the loyalty we have to Jeff’s portrayal; it’s not just fandom; it’s an investment in what made Carl’s world real.

And for those of us who adore Kevin as well, that is another perfect example of how much these vocal performances matter. Kevin’s running commentary has the energy of a sports broadcaster calling a nightmare bloodbath in real time, and it somehow makes the chaos even more unforgettable. These voices are not incidental. They are part of the identity of Dungeon Crawler Carl.

This is also a fanbase with real enthusiasm and real buying power. Many of us have supported the books, audiobooks, merchandise, live shows, and the wider community because this series genuinely means something to us. When an adaptation respects the elements that made the original resonate, fans show up. We watch, we promote, and yes, we spend money.

We say all of this with genuine excitement for what this series could become on screen. We simply hope that excitement is matched by a commitment to preserving the voices that helped make it what it is. Casting Jeff Hays as Princess Donut and the AI, and Ian M. Walker as Kevin, would be one of the clearest ways to do exactly that. After all, none of these roles is likely to use on-screen talent, so the original Voice Artists would be perfect.

Sincerely,

A fandom that knows exactly what made this series hit.