16 November 2026
Open Letter to EHDC Planning Councillors

Dear Planning Councillors,

Re. Planning Applications: EHDC-26-0340-OUT (45 dwellings)

                                          EHDC-25-0774-OUT (88 dwellings)

We are writing to you as concerned residents of Four Marks and the surrounding villages.

The Four Marks Valley

The two planning applications listed above have been included on the agenda for the planning committee meeting on 19th November 2026.

With regard to planning application EHDC-26-0340-OUT – we would like to draw your attention to the consultation end date listed on the EHDC Planning Portal. The Consultation End Date is listed as 20-11-2026. This means that the application is on the agenda to be considered for a decision the day before the listed ‘consultation end date’.

With regards to both planning applications listed above, we have concerns in many areas. Therefore we are requesting that both of these planning applications are removed from the agenda on the 19th November 2026. Our concerns include:

Cumulative impact:

Local residents and local campaign group Fight 4 Four Marks maintain that the cumulative effects of multiple separate planning applications – totalling more than four times the 150 unit rule in the valley area between Alton Lane, Blackberry Lane, Telegraph Lane and Lymington Bottom – should make an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) a necessity to protect existing residents.

If one developer had submitted an application for 636 houses (this figure includes Mount Royal at Lymington Bottom, currently under construction, but still having had a quantifiable impact on the environment), then there is no doubt that they would have been required to carry out an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). The cumulative effect of various smaller applications from different developers needs to be viewed in the same way. It is the same number of houses in the same area. Common sense dictates that the impact on the local human and wildlife community will be exactly the same.

In 2018/19 the same broad area was considered as a larger Four Marks South proposal which was subsequently withdrawn as unacceptable.

The issues then were landscape and settlement character, highway and traffic congestion, infrastructure provision, environmental pressures, flooding risk, and the relationship between the development and the existing settlement.

If these issues prevented development of the area when it was considered as a single larger development, then it stands to reason that the same issues will reappear incrementally through this series of smaller proposals. We believe that the term ‘salami slicing’ is commonly used for this approach - the practice of dividing a single, large-scale development project into multiple smaller, seemingly independent planning applications to bypass regulatory thresholds or environmental rules. While not stating that this is the intent with the current multiple speculative developments, the impact on our village is the same.

Correspondence has been ongoing with the Planning Department since July 2026, when a local resident first wrote to them to request an Environmental Impact Assessment to be carried out on the entire valley area between Alton Lane, Blackberry Lane, Telegraph Lane and Lymington Bottom.

This correspondence has continued, however it is of note that the Planning Department took SEVEN WEEKS to reply to the initial letter – a huge waste of time during a period when planning applications were paused due to The Environment Agency, Natural England, and South East Water having raised alarms regarding how new housing could pressure local water resources and sensitive ecosystems. That time could have been used to explain council procedures on cumulative impact. However, in subsequent replies the Planning Department have failed to concisely answer questions or provide any clear explanation of the procedures that the council employ to assess cumulative impact, insisting that each individual application is assessed on its own merits.

Local residents have received advice from an ecological consultancy that ‘in undertaking any screening assessment, cumulative effects must be considered where they may contribute to significant environmental impacts.’ The reply from EHDC Planning Department only states that ‘cumulative effects can be a relevant consideration where they may contribute to environmental impacts’. As a result of this advice we are currently investigating the issue of how cumulative impact should be assessed by a planning authority. We do not believe that any of these applications should come before the planning committee until local residents, to whom EHDC have a duty of care, have a suitable explanation of how cumulative impact is currently being assessed.

Despite our correspondence and multiple questions, we have no understanding of what criteria would actually trigger a cumulative impact assessment or of how that criteria would be brought to the attention of the Planning Department as they do not seem proactive in seeking to protect current and future residents’ needs with regard to infrastructure, nor in assessing impacts to wildlife.

Water supply:

An AI summary of the Environment Agency position statement regarding risks to the water environment due to water supply pressures related to South East Water’s Water Resource Zone 4-West states the following:

Water supply issues in Thames Water’s WRZ4-West region threaten environmental targets, with a projected deficit of up to 19 Ml/d in dry years due to licensing, infrastructure delays and water quality. Development growth risks increasing environmental harm and security issues, therefore careful planning, demand management and environmental assessments – including cumulative impacts – are essential before approving new developments or infrastructure projects. Short-term mitigation includes demand reduction and treatments upgrades, with future reliance on pipeline delivery and careful regulation of abstraction impacts.

Traffic:

We are aware that local campaign group Fight 4 Four Marks shares the Parish Council's serious concerns about the veracity of the transport information for these applications, which many local residents view as incomplete, and therefore underestimates the effect on our junctions and traffic on the A31 and is an unsafe basis on which to make such an irrevocable decision on these planning applications.

There is a public meeting ‘Can Our Roads Cope?’ organised by the Medstead and Four Marks Neighbourhood Plan group on Monday 23rd November, 7pm at the Four Marks Village Hall.

They have invited all councillors and residents. They are also challenging how the planning committee will be able to make an informed and fair decision on applications when they have such flawed and patchy transport reports.

Barbastelle bats:

Barbastelle bats have been officially recorded in Four Marks and the surrounding area. The dots on the map included with this letter show locations of acoustic records of Barbastelle bats. Barbastelle bats are a European Protected Species, they are in the higher level of protection, Annex II of the Habitats Regulations. Developers must carry out a bat survey when a proposed project could impact Barbastelle bats, their roosts, or their key foraging and commuting habitats (such as mature woodlands, veteran trees, or connected hedgerows and waterways).

Because barbastelle bats are a European Protected Species and one of the UK's rarest mammals, surveys must follow Bat Conservation Trust (BCT) guidelines and be timed according to specific seasonal windows. Has a survey that meets these criteria been carried out for planning applications EHDC-26-0340-OUT (45 dwellings) and EHDC-25-0774-OUT (88 dwellings)?

Local Map of Barbastelle acoustic readings

In summary, we ask on behalf of all local residents that you consider either removing the applications EHDC-26-0340-OUT (45 dwellings) and EHDC-25-0774-OUT (88 dwellings) from the agenda for the Planning Committee meeting on 19th November 2026, or defer a decision on those applications until all of the necessary information is available to accurately assess the full cumulative impact on Four Marks residents, infrastructure and wildlife.

163
signatures
137 verified
  1. Andrew Barnes, Consider Cumulative Impact!, Four Marks
  2. Colin Gamble, Four Marks
  3. Arthur Barlow
  4. Rob MAITLAND, Four Marks
  5. Robert Thomson, Data scientist, Four Marks
  6. JR Maitland, Four Marks
  7. Fiona Chivers, Teaching Support, Lord Wandsworth College, Alton
  8. Andy Patterson, Project Manager, Four Marks
  9. Monica Halliday, N/A, N/A, Alton
  10. David Oswald, Four Marks
  11. Matthew Steven, n/a, n/a, Four Marks
  12. Alan Kayley, Retired architect, N/A, Four Marks
  13. David Carter, Four Marks
  14. Sue Rossell, Four Marks
  15. Vivienne Carter, Four marks
  16. anonymous
  17. Ed Harvey, Retired, Four Marks
  18. Sarah Batchelor, Four Marks
  19. lawrence batchelor, Driver, four marks
  20. Julia Huggan, Retired, Resident, Four Marks
...
97 more
verified signatures
  1. Heidi-Natalie Reid, Alton
  2. Jill Kayley, Retired, Four Marks
  3. Tim Grey, Manager, Four Marks
  4. Jenny Norman, Four Marks
  5. Martin camp, Retired, Alton
  6. Chris Starr, Chief Financial Officer, Alton
  7. anonymous
  8. Karen O’Reilly, Retured, Four Marks
  9. Cheryl Malam, Four Marks
  10. Charlie hesk
  11. Angelo Guttoriello, Retired, Four Marks, Alton
  12. Katie Steven, Four Marks
  13. Louisa Carey, Veterinary nurse assistant, Alton
  14. anonymous, Four marks
  15. Alison Tubman, Medstead
  16. Helen Wright, Retired, Medstead Alton
  17. Catriona Knight, Four Marks
  18. Charlotte, Retail, Bp, Fourmarks
  19. Andrew Dinsley, Civil Servant, Government - UK, Alton
  20. Clare Klaire, Retired, A31 Alliance, Chawton